Rabbi Ross. Along with all your many readers, I want to thank you for you Avodas Hakodesh. Your advice is inspiring, and although there are some articles which I don’t agree with, by and large my wife and I have gained tremendously for your hard work. You wrote a long time ago that siblings fight. We’re ok with the kids fighting once in a while. What bothers us, is when they talk to each other. They say these horrible insults, comments which I’m too embarrassed to even put on paper. I would prefer they fought physically and get over it. These stinging insults are just so mean and we’re both really frustrated. Any advice would be much appreciated. Dovid - Flatbush
Firstly, thank you for your kind words. And I’d be concerned with anybody who agreed 100% with what I say. I like to categorize sibling rivalry into three types. The first is childish banter. “I’m way better at baseball than you are.” The second is physical fighting. The third, is the malicious comments that you’re talking about. Many parents have told me that these harsh comments usually begin once they enter their teenage years. For those of you that aren’t aware of what comments we’re talking about, I’ll list a few that have been sent to me. “I wish you were never born.” “I truly hate having you as a brother” “You are the dumbest person I have ever met”. And these are the “nicer” ones. As parents, it’s so hurtful, not just because of what’s being said, but even more so, the malicious tone being used. One mother described it as hatred oozing from her child’s soul. It’s not. It feels like your children have this deep-rooted hatred of one another, but they really don’t. It’s usually frustration about other things, and siblings are just an easy target. I haven’t ever done a formal study, but most siblings that don’t get along as kids seem to be fine later in life. Some siblings joke about their younger days, others pretend it never happened. I’m not saying that you should ignore this behavior. On the contrary, this needs to be dealt with. However, it’s important to understand what the issue really is. The fact that he’s venting by saying mean things to his siblings, tells us that he needs a better outlet for his frustration. He’s obviously angry or frustrated and is saying harmful things. The goal here should be:
YR
12 Comments
Devora
5/17/2018 06:07:40 pm
Great Article. I'm a social worker, and I'm constantly telling people this. If you don't make the sibling rivalries into a big deal, they won't become one.
Reply
Private
5/17/2018 06:09:01 pm
Wow! This article was early. I figured it would be about Shavuos, but siblings are always a fun topic. You're on point with this article. I fought with my brother all the time, and my parents didn't make a big deal out of it. We are now super close.
Reply
Mattis Lowy
5/17/2018 08:03:29 pm
I am so impressed with this email. This is my first week, and I'm seriously blown away! One of the worst mistakes I made when my children were younger was making every fight into a court date. The results were so horrible, and my children still suffer from it. whenever possible, try to make it about each child separately, and keep the sibling issues to a minimum.
Reply
Joshua Cohen
5/17/2018 08:11:34 pm
I was getting nervous until I read the last point. That is key. You need to confront the elephant in the room - the unacceptable behavior, to the sibling. Let him know that you are dealing with the issue of the inappropriate comment very seriously. This way you can head off issues with him or her.
Reply
Sara B.
5/17/2018 08:14:28 pm
Thank you for this article. I do have a question. What if the child in question uses curse words. does this change anything?
Reply
Devora
5/17/2018 08:17:44 pm
It really depends on the words used. You need to ascertain where he learned the words from and make sure he understands why he can't say them again.
Reply
Rabbi Ross
5/17/2018 08:23:04 pm
Sara, thanks for your question. I will be publishing an article in a few weeks that discusses that topic. If a child uses curse words in the situation we described above, it really shouldn't change anything. We used the term "inappropriate" and curse words certainly fall into that category.
Reply
S.L.
5/17/2018 08:25:38 pm
Well, I was fascinated by the fact that the person asking the question said that he would rather they psychically fought. I'm not sure if that's a great statement. In my house, once physical contact is used, it changes everything. That is my red line.
Reply
Kayla Dombrovsky
5/17/2018 08:35:55 pm
I'm sorry if this is too long of a response. I grew up where every little spat was mediated by my mother. She would call in me and my siblings, sit us down, and make us talk through everything. I guess she was playing psychologist, but my siblings (who will probably read this comment) and I hated it. In fact, what stopped us from fighting wasn't any consequence except the fact that we would have to sit down.
Reply
Shira L.
5/17/2018 09:45:27 pm
This made me cry. It's scary how many parents are convinced they are doing the right thing even though they are hurting the people they love. I think you should sit with your siblings and make up. At the very least, send this article to your mother!
Reply
Chaim Leib
5/18/2018 04:31:20 am
Agreed. I would add on one more thing. Tell your son that you love him. It’s always good to reassure him of this.
Reply
A Bubby & Zaidy
5/18/2018 07:24:50 am
It’s normal to be hurt when your kids fight. It’s also normal for kids to fight. When we were younger, we would just tell the kids, you can continue this argument when you’re 18 years old. They didn’t care that much to continue any of the arguments.
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorRabbi Yitzie Ross is a Rebbe and has been working with parents and kids for many years. You can read more about him in the "about" section. Archives
March 2020
Categories |