Rabbi Ross,
Not to beat a dead horse, but I wanted to thank you for these e-mails. I’m sure it takes a lot of time and it’s greatly appreciated. I was hoping you could settle an argument I’m having with my husband. Every year, our Seder lasts for around 5 hours. Although he really tries keeping it fun for the kids, I truly believe it would be a better Seder if it lasted 3 hours. What are your thoughts please? Esther – Far Rockaway. Thank you for your kind words. I would love to say “It’s not about how long it lasts; it’s about how much the kids are engaged!” However, I do believe that the two are connected. Many boys have told me over the years how “Long and boring” their Sedorim are. It seems therefore, that many children do connect the length with loss of interest. Without knowing the ages, temperaments and family dynamic, it’s hard to suggest a specific time limit for your Seder. However, I will share with you some great ideas of how to make your Seder interesting for your children.
Rabbi Ross
18 Comments
Daniel
4/20/2016 07:15:14 pm
Great points! Our Seder was very long when I was a kid, so I keep it shorter.
Reply
Cheskel Tykovitz
4/20/2016 07:18:56 pm
As a boy, my Tatty would have a very fast Seder, and then let the older kids stay up to discuss Divrei Torah. This was a win-win for everyone.
Reply
Baila L.
4/20/2016 07:20:32 pm
Thank you for number 10. It's nice to be appreciated.
Reply
Shaya L.
4/20/2016 07:28:11 pm
Such a great article! It's all about the kids.
Reply
David
4/20/2016 08:04:03 pm
Great point on the alcohol. Too often, we make alcohol a focal point of Yom Tov and Shabbos.
Reply
Rabbi Ross
4/20/2016 08:06:38 pm
Thank you David. I agree with you.
Reply
Hadassah
4/20/2016 08:05:01 pm
I noticed that you didn't bring up the cons of going to a hotel for Yom Tov. What thoughts do you have on making Pesach into a vacation?
Reply
Rabbi Ross
4/20/2016 08:12:39 pm
I get the feeling you are not a fan of hotels. Yes, there are cons, but there are some serious pros as well. Many mothers enjoy Yom Tov because they go away, otherwise they are working too hard to appreciate everything. I think it’s a personal preference. If the kids are happy and are loving Yiddishkeit, it’s all good.
Reply
Shaya Termechi
4/20/2016 08:29:48 pm
Your last point was interesting. If it's so important for the mothers to relax, shouldn't we slow the Seder down?
Reply
Rabbi Ross
4/20/2016 08:37:23 pm
I don't like to think about the Seder in terms of length. I do think that we should try to keep it exciting for the children. There are those that like to have a "Long" Seder, so they can come to shul and say "We finished at 3:00". That is wrong.
Reply
Arielle
4/20/2016 08:39:12 pm
Rabbi Ross said nothing about going fast, he just doesn't want people going super slow. I'm on board. A good night's sleep is important also.
Reply
Private
4/20/2016 08:31:11 pm
Great article again. This should be posted in hotels all over for Yom Tov. It's not how long, it's how the kids are enjoying.
Reply
Sam D.
4/21/2016 06:48:11 am
Pesach is always about the kids. I know men that argue about whose Seder lasted longer. So sad.
Reply
Sarah Davidowitz
4/21/2016 07:14:27 am
Very well put. Forwarding to my family.
Reply
Shira
4/21/2016 08:14:24 am
Another idea is to look over your kids sheets before the Seder to have an idea as to what you need to focus on. Thank you.
Reply
Erica
4/21/2016 08:36:11 am
Thank you for this article. At the risk of generalizing, usually fathers like the longer Sedorim. If it's for Divrei Torah, that's fine. If it's wasting time, it's more of a problem.
Reply
Zahava Aranov
4/21/2016 12:44:02 pm
This email sounds like the conversation that takes place in our home every year. I agree 1000%. My husband does not. It's so important that we make these Sedorim kid oriented. Thank You.
Reply
Jason
4/21/2016 01:57:39 pm
Just got this in Florida. Beautifully written and so accurate. Thanks!
Reply
Your comment will be posted after it is approved.
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorRabbi Yitzie Ross is a Rebbe and has been working with parents and kids for many years. You can read more about him in the "about" section. Archives
March 2020
Categories |